Objective Design Standards and Streamlined Project Review

Oakland is starting a process to develop procedures, regulations, and objective design and development standards to streamline the approval of residential, mixed-use, and commercial building types.

Why is Oakland Undertaking This Effort?

Building photo
  • Oakland is in the midst of a housing crisis that includes rising costs, increased rent burden, displacement, and widespread demographic change. At the root of this crisis is the limited availability of housing in Oakland, especially housing available to moderate- and low-income residents. The City is working on multiple fronts to increase the available supply of affordable housing and housing in general.
  • California recently adopted legislation to address the housing shortage within the State. These new laws require that the City review new multi-family developments and residential mixed-use developments ministerially or "over-the-counter" against objective standards instead through a more subjective design review process open to interpretation.
  • The City of Oakland also applied for and received a State planning grant funding used to develop and implement policies that will expedite housing development and increase housing supply in the City of Oakland. A portion of this grant funds will cover a housing-related share of this project.
  • The objective design standards will be also applied more broadly to projects consisting of a wide array of mixed-use and commercial building types throughout the City of Oakland. The creation of standards for non-housing-related projects will come from a separate funding source. The State SB-2 grant funds will only be used for housing-related project items.
  • The objective design standards developed during this project must be sensitive to the historic context of existing neighborhoods to protect and enhance the historic heritage of Oakland.

What Are Objective Design Standards?

Montage of buildings
  • State law defines an "objective" standard as one that involves no personal or subjective judgment by a public official. Objective standards are uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or a "check list" available and knowable by both the development applicant and the public official prior to submittal.
  • In contrast, subjective standards require interpretation and discretion. It can be a more time-consuming process of discovery and evaluation. For example, a front yard setback requirement of 4 feet is an objective standard while “front yard setback consistent with the character of the neighborhood” is subjective because it requires a discretionary review and determination as to what “consistent with the character of the neighborhood” means.

Project Timeline

This process timeline is designed to give potential consultants a quick overview of the potential length of the project. A more detailed project timeline with specific steps and stages will be developed once a project consultant has been selected.

  • February 2022 - RFP Launch

    RFP release, pre-proposal meeting, questions and answers, addenda as necessary

  • March - April 2022 - Proposal Evaluation

    Deadline for submissions, proposal evaluations, notification of finalists, interviews with finalists

  • April - May 2022 - Consultant Team Selection

    Confirmation of the Consultant Team and contract negotiations

  • May - June 2022 - Project Kickoff

    Work on Objective Design Standards commences (through May 2023)

  • May - June 2023 - Standards Finalized and Considered

    Objective Design Standards delivered for consideration by the Planning Commission and City Council

Project Team

  • Ed Manasse - Deputy Director of Planning
  • Laura Kaminski - Strategic Planning Manager
  • Ruslan Filipau – Planner III, Project Manager

About

The City of Oakland's Objective Design Standards project will develop processes, procedures, regulations, and objective design and development standards to streamline the approval of a wide range of residential, mixed-use, and commercial building types, with a particular focus on the much-needed affordable housing projects in transit-rich areas. As opposed to "design guidelines,” objective design standards will not be subject to interpretation and design review, and result in faster, more predictable approvals of high-quality development that respects Oakland's history and benefits the local community.

Contact Us

Email Address