Public Ethics Commission Enforcement Actions Chart

View our most recent actions. For a more complete list, download the data set below.

Download

Complete PEC Complaint Data set

Date Posted: January 27th, 2020 @ 3:44 PM
Last Updated: February 23rd, 2021 @ 11:35 AM

Enforcement Actions

This page is being continuously updated. For a complete list, please download the dataset found above.

2021

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
2/1/2021	In the Matter of Roma Groves-Walton, Complaint 20-36	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
2/1/2021	In the Matter of the City of Oakland Rent Board, Complaint 20-42	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
1/4/2021	In the Matter of Department of Human Services, Complaint 17-12M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings

2020

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
11/2/2020	In the Matter of Carol Fife, Complaint 20-35	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

Closure Date

Complaint

Action

Violation

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Lynette Gibson-McElhaney (Councilmemeber) and Barbara Parker (City Attorney ), Complaint 17-17

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Attorney Barbara Parker, Complaint 20-10

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-12

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-13

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-14

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-15

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-16

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-17

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-18

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-19

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-20

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-21

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-22

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-23

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-25

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-26

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-27

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-28

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-29

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-30

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Oakland City Council Members et. al, Complaint 20-31

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of Rich Fielding, Planning and Building Department, Complaint 16-11

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

10/5/2020

In the Matter of the Oakland City Auditor Courtney Ruby, Complaint 20-32

Dismissed

Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
7/6/2020	In the Matter of City Attorney Barbara Parker and Coucilmember Rebecca Kaplan, Complaint 20-09	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
7/6/2020	In the Matter of City of Oakland, Complaint 16-15M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
7/6/2020	In the Matter of the City of Oakland Department of Building and Planning, Complaint M2019-17	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
7/6/2020	In the Matter of Dorian Gray, Complaint 18-03	Fine	Government Ethics Act 2.25.060C

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
5/4/2020	In the Matter of the Bridge Association of Realtors, Complaint 20-07	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
5/4/2020	In the Matter of the National Realtors Association, Complaint 20-08	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
3/2/2020	In the Matter of Libby Schaaf, Complaint 19-20	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
3/2/2020	In the matter of the City of Oakland Public Works, Complaint 20-02	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
2/3/2020	In the Matter of City Council, Complaint 19-19	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
2/3/2020	In the matter of the City of Oakland Public Works, Complaint 20-01	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
1/6/2020	In the matter of the City of Oakland Public Works, Complaint 19-21	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
1/6/2020	In the matter of of Mike Rivera of the City of Oaklan Planning and building Department, Complaint 19-22	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
1/6/2020	In the Matter of PMACC DBA Harborside Health Center, Complaint 16-06	Dismissed	Insufficient evidence to support investigation
1/6/2020	In the Matter of Michael Colbruno, Complaint 16-01	Fine	Lobbyist Registration Act 3.20.040 & 3.20.110

2019

Closure Date	Complaint	Action	Violation
12/2/2019	In the Matter of the City of Oakland Planning Department, Complaint M2019-06	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
12/2/2019	In the Matter of Joseph Betesh, Complaint 19-07	Fine – Streamline	Campaign rules
12/2/2019	In the Matter of Mayor Libby Schaff, Complaint M2019-02	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
12/2/2019	In the Matter of Jumoke Hinton Hodge, Monique Rivera, Re-Elect Jumoke Hinton Hodge for Oakland School Board 2016, Complaint 17-07	Fine – Streamline	Oakland Campaign Reform Act 3.12.240
12/2/2019	In the Matter of ShotSpotter, Complaint 14-29	Fine	Lobbyist Registration Act 3.12.140
12/2/2019	In the Matter of Council Member Dan Kalb, Complaint M2019-11	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
11/4/2019	In the Matter of Alameda County Taxpayers Association, Complaint 18-38	Dismissed	Referred to another agency
11/4/2019	In the Matter of Amber Todd, Complaint 19-02	Dismissed	Withdrawn by complainant
11/4/2019	In the Matter of the City Auditor Brenda Roberts, Complaint 18-28	Dismissed	Insufficient evidence to support investigation
11/4/2019	In the Matter of the City Auditor Brenda Roberts, Complaint 18-29	Dismissed	Insufficient evidence to support investigation
11/4/2019	In the Matter of the Oakland Police Department, Complaint M2019-13	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
11/4/2019	In the Matter of CM Brooks, Complaint 15-04	Advisory Letter	Oakland Campaign Reform Act 3.12.050 3.12.080
11/4/2019	In the Matter of the City of Oakland Finance Department; Case No. 18-37M., Complaint 18-37M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
11/4/2019	In the Matter of Dana King, Complaint 15-03b	Advisory Letter	Oakland Campaign Reform Act 3.12.050 3.12.080
10/7/2019	In the Matter of Melanie Shelby, Complaint 15-03a	Warning Letter	Oakland Campaign Reform Act 3.12.050 3.12.080
10/7/2019	In the Matter of Katano Kasaine, Director of the Department of Finance, Complaint M2019-12	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
9/24/2019	In the Matter of Renee Sykes, OPD, Complaint 19-15	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
9/19/2019	In the Matter of Desley Brooks, Complaint 18-23	No action	Government Ethics Act 2.25.060(A)
8/5/2019	In the Matter of CM Larry Reid, Complaint 18-01	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
8/5/2019	In the Matter City Council Members, Complaint 19-11	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
8/5/2019	In the Matter of Mayor Libby Schaff, Complaint 19-09	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
8/5/2019	In the Matter of the City Council, Complaint 18-50	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
8/5/2019	In the Matter of Mark Forte; Libby Schaaf; City Council, Complaint M2019-01	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
8/5/2019	In the Matter of Anne Kirkpatrick, Complaint 19-10	Warning Letter	Ethics
6/4/2019	In the Matter of City Administrator Office, City Attorney, Alex Katz, Alexandra Orologas, Amber Todd, Richard Luna, Sabrina Landreth, Complaint 18-06M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
6/4/2019	In the Matter of Joanne Karchmer, Complaint 18-39M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
6/4/2019	In the Matter of City of Oakland Attorney Barbara Parker, Alex Katz, Mark Forte, City Administrator staff Amber Todd, Complaint 18-02M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
6/4/2019	In the Matter of Amber Danielle-Rose Todd, Complaint 18-24M	Mediated	Public records/Open meetings
6/3/2019	In the Matter of Cesar Avila, Complaint 19-08	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction
6/3/2019	In the Matter of City of Oakland Building Department, Complaint 19-05	Dismissed	Not a violation within PEC enforcement jurisdiction